Defamation – Civil and Criminal Remedies
For a false, damaging statement made about you – in person, in print, or increasingly on social media – India recognises both a criminal complaint and a separate civil suit for damages, and you can pursue either or both.
Steps
- 1. Identify what was said/published and preserve evidence immediately.Screenshot the post/message/article with visible timestamps and URLs – social media content can be deleted quickly, so capture it as soon as you become aware.
- 2. Decide between the criminal and civil route, or both – they are independent.A criminal complaint seeks punishment of the person who defamed you; a civil suit seeks monetary damages for the harm caused to your reputation. Filing one does not bar the other.
- 3. For the criminal route, file a complaint directly before a Magistrate.Defamation under BNS s.356 (successor to IPC ss.499-500) is generally not a cognizable offence – police typically won't register an FIR or investigate on their own; the standard route is a private complaint filed directly before a Judicial Magistrate under BNSS s.223 (successor to CrPC s.200), who examines you and any witnesses before deciding whether to proceed.
- 4. Know the recognised exceptions where a statement is NOT defamation.BNS s.356's exceptions cover, among others, a true statement made for the public good, fair comment on a public matter, and a statement made in good faith about a person's conduct in the discharge of public functions – a court examines whether an exception applies before finding defamation.
- 5. For the civil route, send a legal notice, then file a suit for damages if unresolved.A civil suit for defamation is filed in the ordinary civil court, seeking monetary compensation for damage to reputation – often preceded by a legal notice demanding a retraction/apology, which can itself sometimes resolve the matter without litigation.
- 6. For online defamation, also consider reporting to the platform.A platform's own report form is the fastest practical step, but a private report or legal notice does not oblige a platform to remove anything; removal is guaranteed only by a court order (or a binding government direction), and a platform that ignores a court order risks losing its safe-harbour protection under the IT Act. Use the platform's complaint process and, where the harm is serious, ask the court for an order.
- 7. Understand punishment/damages are not automatic or guaranteed.A criminal conviction can mean simple imprisonment up to 2 years, a fine, or both; a civil court decides damages based on the actual harm shown – neither outcome is guaranteed, and truth or a recognised exception is a complete defence.
Good to Know
Handled by: Judicial Magistrate First Class (criminal complaint); Civil Court (damages suit)
Who can use this: Anyone whose reputation has been harmed by a false statement made, published, or spoken by another person, in any medium.
This does not cover: Does not cover a genuine, good-faith opinion or fair comment on a public matter – BNS s.356's own exceptions protect this. Does not cover a workplace/service-related grievance framed as defamation without an actual defamatory publication. Does not guarantee content removal from a platform – that depends on the platform's own policies or a court order.
Time limit: Criminal complaint: no fixed filing deadline under BNS, though a Magistrate examines delay in deciding whether to proceed. Civil suit for damages: 1 year from the date of the defamatory statement. (Limitation Act, 1963, Article 75)
Cost: Court fee for a civil suit is ad valorem, based on the damages claimed; a criminal complaint before a Magistrate has a nominal fee.
- The exact statement made and where/when it was published
- The identity of the person who made the statement, if known
- How the statement has harmed your reputation
- Whether you have already sent a demand/legal notice
- Any witnesses to the statement, if made verbally
- Screenshots/printouts of the defamatory content with visible timestamps/URLs
- Any legal notice already sent and proof of delivery
- Evidence of actual harm (lost business, social/professional consequences)
- Witness statements, for a verbal statement
What happens after: A criminal complaint, if the Magistrate takes cognizance, proceeds to trial with the possibility of imprisonment up to 2 years and/or a fine on conviction. A civil suit, if successful, results in a damages award; either can also be settled at any stage, including through a retraction/apology.
Legal Remedies Available
These are the remedies Indian law provides for this kind of situation – not a recommendation, and not every remedy will apply to your own facts.
Common Questions
Can I get someone arrested immediately for defaming me on social media?
No, not automatically. Defamation under BNS s.356 is generally not a cognizable offence, so the police won't investigate or arrest on their own – you file a private complaint directly before a Magistrate, who examines you and any witnesses before deciding whether to proceed.
Is criticising a public figure's work or a business's service always defamation?
No. Fair comment on a public matter, and a true statement made for the public good, are both recognised exceptions under BNS s.356 – honest criticism and genuine opinion are generally protected, though the line depends on the specific facts.
Can I sue for defamation AND file a criminal complaint for the same statement?
Yes. The criminal complaint and the civil suit are independent remedies – one seeks punishment, the other seeks monetary compensation – and pursuing one does not bar the other.
How long do I have to file a civil defamation suit?
Generally 1 year from the date of the defamatory statement, under Article 75 of the Limitation Act, 1963 – don't delay if you intend to pursue civil damages.
Will the platform take down a defamatory post just because I ask?
No, not by right. A request or legal notice does not compel a platform to remove a post; the platform decides under its own policies, and it is bound to remove content only when a court orders it or a competent authority directs it under the IT Act and Rules. Report through the platform's own process and send a legal notice in parallel, but ask the court for an order if the content is serious and stays up.
Doesn't criminalising defamation violate free speech?
No – in Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India, (2016) 7 SCC 221, the Supreme Court directly considered and rejected this challenge, upholding BNS s.356's predecessor (IPC ss.499-500) as a reasonable restriction on free speech under Article 19(2), given the equally fundamental right to reputation under Article 21.
Governing law: Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, s.356 (successor to IPC ss.499-500)
Source: Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, s.356 (successor to IPC ss.499-500); Limitation Act, 1963, Article 75. Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India, (2016) 7 SCC 221.
Aadhrix does not decide which route applies to you. This describes the official process as published — consider an advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Dealing with this yourself?
Track it in your own Aadhrix – keep the documents, dates, and follow-ups together in one place, free.
Track this in your own Aadhrix